PDA

View Full Version : Change "delete post" behavior for start-of-thread


Terry Kennedy
04-19-2004, 10:02 AM
Hi -

In a number of cases, I have posted information in a thread, only to have the whole thread disappear when the original poster deletes the first post in the thread. In at least some of those cases, this has caused the loss of useful information. A case in point is the recent thread about key initialization, where I posted a (IMHO) well-thought-out reply describing the 3 methods a BMW key uses. Unfortunately, the original poster deleted their note and that information was lost. That is only the most recent example of this problem.

I would like to suggest that deleting a start-of-thread post no longer be allowed. I understand that with the software we use, it isn't possible to delete a start-of-thread post and keep the rest of the thread, so perhaps the original poster could just edit their post to remove all the text (or, even better, have the software automatically offer that if they try to delete a start-of-thread post).

In those few cases where deleting the whole thread is called for, it will generally have come to the attention of the forum moderators or site admins, so the thread creator could simply request that one of the moderators / admins perform the deletion. In the case I mentioned above, I believe the thread starter was a moderator. Despite the fact that moderators could delete their own threads under my proposal, simply saying "please don't do that" should suffice.

Comments?

TD
04-19-2004, 10:03 AM
Simple solution- Don't post in threads started by Dave330i (and put him on your ignore list so that you're not tempted to reply).

Terry Kennedy
04-19-2004, 10:07 AM
Simple solution- Don't post in threads started by Dave330i (and put him on your ignore list so that you're not tempted to reply).I don't believe the thread I refer to was started by Dave330i. But any moderator could go look in the deleted posts archive and check to make sure... :dunno:

___lk___
04-19-2004, 05:14 PM
absurd idea. if u have such a great bit of info to share, start your own thread.

Terry Kennedy
04-19-2004, 06:11 PM
absurd idea. if u have such a great bit of info to share, start your own thread.Huh? If someone posts something I feel like replying to, you're saying I should ignore that thread and create a new thread for my reply? That doesn't seem reasonable...

tim330i
04-19-2004, 07:49 PM
I agree that the need for thread delete is limited, however i can only imaging the flood of *****ing that would start if we removed it.

Tim

Terry Kennedy
04-19-2004, 07:58 PM
I agree that the need for thread delete is limited, however i can only imaging the flood of *****ing that would start if we removed it.How about allowing the current behavior in the various off-topic forums, but implementing some flavor of my suggestion in the technical forums?

·clyde·
04-20-2004, 05:31 AM
How about allowing the current behavior in the various off-topic forums, but implementing some flavor of my suggestion in the technical forums?
I like it the way it is now. For the most part, the privilege is only abused by a handful of people. Generally, if someone starts a thread, I think they should have the ability to delete it for whatever reason no matter whether the thread is non-sensical and meaningless or worthy of archiving for future generations. I don't like seeing threads deleted, particularly when there is worthwhile info in them, but it rarely happens. Occasionally, somone gets screwed, but I tihnk it's a fair price to pay to have this freedom that is absent on many other boards. Just my two cents.