Bimmerfest - BMW Forums

Bimmerfest - BMW Forums (http://www.bimmerfest.com/forums/index.php)
-   X5 E70 (2007 - 2013) (http://www.bimmerfest.com/forums/forumdisplay.php?f=159)
-   -   X5d vs VW Touareg2 diesel (http://www.bimmerfest.com/forums/showthread.php?t=407571)

dcharnet 10-25-2009 07:25 AM

X5d vs VW Touareg2 diesel
 
My 08 3.0 at 41,800k is reaching the end of its warranty and I am looking at options. It has surprisingly solid trade/sale value, and I am looking at moving to a new diesel. The candidates are the X5d and the Touareg2 diesel. One of the appeals of the latter is, " and now for something completely different," to borrow a phrase from Monte Python. Another is the increasing sense I have that, although BMW builds good products, it has lost some significant degree of integrity and post-sale customer orientation--for example, its shameful response to the premature auto trans problems to early 2000 3- series cars. Comments on the Touareg or other aspects of the above?

XXX555 10-25-2009 09:36 AM

The VW has won at least one recent comparison test (?Motortrend) that I recall and is a good value but it does not excite like the/a BMW from my perspective.

UncleJ 10-25-2009 11:26 AM

The Q7 diesel might be a better fit, given they have three rows like the X5. The ML and GL also offer diesel. The new improved T-egg II is supposed to be vastly better than the original in terms of reliablity etc. They do have a great interior too IMHO.

Marshotel 10-25-2009 04:51 PM

My two cents........I have never owned a TDI but I have owned both vehicles and I think you are better off with the BMW. I had a 2002 X5, when I got rid of that I picked up a new 2006 touareg V6. Although they are comparable in many ways, the maintenance on the touareg extremely expensive and they have the worst service. In my opinion BMW ultimate service is the deciding factor which is why I am picking up my 2010 X5 on Friday. Like I said, the Touareg was nice and compared well to the X5 bit isn't a BMW.

Craig B 10-25-2009 05:54 PM

I've had a part on order for 3 months with BMW for a check engine light. I wouldn't say BMW's service is great. I had to put a call into BMWNA 2 weeks ago to ask where my part is. That's unacceptable in my opinion... The only problem I've had with mine is a check engine light that's been on for the last 3 months.

Craig

Penguin 10-25-2009 06:22 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Craig B (Post 4628624)
I had to put a call into BMWNA 2 weeks ago to ask where my part is. That's unacceptable in my opinion...Craig


What did BMWNA say?

ard 10-25-2009 06:22 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Craig B (Post 4628624)
I've had a part on order for 3 months with BMW for a check engine light. I wouldn't say BMW's service is great. I had to put a call into BMWNA 2 weeks ago to ask where my part is. That's unacceptable in my opinion... The only problem I've had with mine is a check engine light that's been on for the last 3 months.

Craig

What part? Part number?

Certainly 3 months is unacceptable, but the squeaky wheel gets the grease. ...

Here in CA I'd bet that driving around with the CEL effectively disabled (ie on all the time, no way to tell when a new code is set) is a violation of some regulation. If you were in a loaner rest assured it wouldn't have been three months...

If your point is "I shouldn't have to complain" you are absolutely right. And waiting.

A

Marshotel 10-25-2009 07:35 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Craig B (Post 4628624)
I've had a part on order for 3 months with BMW for a check engine light. I wouldn't say BMW's service is great. I had to put a call into BMWNA 2 weeks ago to ask where my part is. That's unacceptable in my opinion... The only problem I've had with mine is a check engine light that's been on for the last 3 months.

Craig

I guess I am lucky, my local BMW service center is great. They are very responsive. One big plus with BMW is the use of a loaner when you bring in your vehicle for service. No such luck with VW no matter what you are bringing it in for.

I just looked at the VW site and they are now doing a similare maintenance program called Carefree Maintenance but I am sure it isn't as extensive as BMW Ultimate service

Craig B 10-26-2009 09:12 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Penguin (Post 4628677)
What did BMWNA say?

I called BMWNA and had a case manager open a case two weeks ago. She called back in two days to tell me the part will be here in 10-14 working days. My part was ordered by my local dealership Aug. 4th. The part is an air temp. sensor. Sorry, I don't have the part number. About 3 weeks ago my dealer re-ordered the part as critical. I'm tired of waiting for the part. I find it unacceptable....

Craig

UncleJ 10-26-2009 09:51 AM

Well, Jerry reports he is getting his new engine "sometime this week", so the parts system does apparently work so hang in there!

Craig B 10-26-2009 01:49 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by UncleJ (Post 4629965)
Well, Jerry reports he is getting his new engine "sometime this week", so the parts system does apparently work so hang in there!

Thanks, maybe they ship parts in the trunk of cars coming over from Germany. I can't explain why it's taking them so long to get this part to my local dealer...

Craig

Penguin 10-26-2009 02:07 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Craig B (Post 4630728)
I can't explain why it's taking them so long to get this part to my local dealer...

Craig


Sometimes a part goes bad because there is a bad batch or a design error. So the demand might be very high if they are seeing a lot of failures. If they have identified a flaw and made a change in design, often they will wait until the new design version is out, particularly if it is not a part that takes the "Vehicle Off Road." I'm not 100% sure about the terminology, but I believe the high-priority code for a BMW parts order is "VOR," meaning the vehicle is not operable until the repair part is obtained.

I needed a $900 final drive for my K75S motorcycle a few years ago and the parts guy said he put a VOR code on the order, which resulted in it being airfreighted from Germany.

ard 10-26-2009 03:12 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Craig B (Post 4630728)
Thanks, maybe they ship parts in the trunk of cars coming over from Germany. I can't explain why it's taking them so long to get this part to my local dealer...

Craig

I'd be taking a LONG test drive in a demo car, maybe the old lady could distract the CA, pop the hood.... and that would solve my problem!


:yikes:

A

XXX555 10-26-2009 04:51 PM

T2 clone review:

http://www.detnews.com/article/20091...312/1148/rss25

pedah3 10-27-2009 12:29 PM

Had the opportunity to take an extended drive in a T-Reg TDI and was most impressed. Engine is much smoother and quieter than my 35d. I'd say performance "feels" about the same. Pulls like crazy off the line just like the 35d. Size is a little smaller, but still very good for 5 when needed. Electronics (Nav, Stereo) much better than the i-drive stuff. I have not seen the new 2010 update to the electronics, so this may not be as much of an issue.

dcharnet 10-27-2009 07:40 PM

Did you happen to note the wheel size? I am wondering about the harshness of 19 inch wheels and tires with an AR of 45.

HT417 10-27-2009 09:25 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by dcharnet (Post 4634759)
Did you happen to note the wheel size? I am wondering about the harshness of 19 inch wheels and tires with an AR of 45.

It's probably not harsh at all. From all that I've read, the Touareg is rather softly sprung with the standard coils.


All times are GMT -7. The time now is 12:14 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2014, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.
© 2001-2011 performanceIX, Inc. All Rights Reserved .: guidelines .:. privacy .:. terms