Bimmerfest - BMW Forums

Bimmerfest - BMW Forums (http://www.bimmerfest.com/forums/index.php)
-   X5 E70 (2007 - 2013) (http://www.bimmerfest.com/forums/forumdisplay.php?f=159)
-   -   The Standard Stereo in a 2011 X5 (http://www.bimmerfest.com/forums/showthread.php?t=519043)

onefish2 02-10-2011 06:46 PM

The Standard Stereo in a 2011 X5
 
Just picked up a X5 35i Premium today. I will keep this short and sweet. I am am music fanatic. I have over 1500 CDs, 65,000 songs in iTunes, been to over 100 concerts, 10+ ipods over the years, 3 stereos in my house and iPod docks all over my house too. I am a music perfectionist. Maybe even an audiophile.

The standard stereo in the X5 is just fine. If you listen to mp3s, Sirius or FM radio... well all of those are poor sources to begin with. If you only listen to CDs while the car is parked then maybe, just maybe you won't like the stereo.

Its a good car stereo. Its in your car. Not in your living room.

0428 02-10-2011 08:08 PM

To all those who claim the standard audio is crap, re-read again the above post, an honest opinion from an audiophile. :yikes:

By the way, who still listens to CDs?

quackbury 02-10-2011 08:25 PM

I do, when I can't get the 8 track to work.

samsonitep 02-11-2011 06:15 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by 0428 (Post 5840273)
To all those who claim the standard audio is crap, re-read again the above post, an honest opinion from an audiophile. :yikes:

By the way, who still listens to CDs?

problem is...when you turn the base volume up..it gets just "louder" highs and lows are not amplified.


I like to think of the base radio as an AM station....turn it up louder and it still sucks, but just hurts your ears.


That being said, I tried the base/premium and both were terrible.( I have the base on the 50i which seems to be a step up from the 35i??????)

better off getting the base and putting your own in.

0428 02-11-2011 07:10 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by quackbury (Post 5840322)
I do, when I can't get the 8 track to work.

8 track? wtf is that? I tried googling it, and it comes back telling me their database does not go back beyond the stone age.

pk9394 02-11-2011 07:21 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by quackbury (Post 5840322)
I do, when I can't get the 8 track to work.

LOL, maybe the new camaro has that option :rofl:

ckm1515 02-11-2011 08:07 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by onefish2 (Post 5840081)
Just picked up a X5 35i Premium today. I will keep this short and sweet. I am am music fanatic. I have over 1500 CDs, 65,000 songs in iTunes, been to over 100 concerts, 10+ ipods over the years, 3 stereos in my house and iPod docks all over my house too. I am a music perfectionist. Maybe even an audiophile.

The standard stereo in the X5 is just fine. If you listen to mp3s, Sirius or FM radio... well all of those are poor sources to begin with. If you only listen to CDs while the car is parked then maybe, just maybe you won't like the stereo.

Its a good car stereo. Its in your car. Not in your living room.

I hvae the premium in mine and when compared to the base, sounded a bit crisper to me. Probably all in my head but I like bangin' music in my ride. After 60K+ price tag, another $1,200 didn't really faze me

winterk 02-11-2011 09:08 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by 0428 (Post 5841036)
8 track? wtf is that? I tried googling it, and it comes back telling me their database does not go back beyond the stone age.

Hahaha :beerchug:

I have to disagree with the initial post though, the base audio is crap, one of the worst I've heard especially on a $60k luxury car. I don't know what type of kool-aid you're drinking that makes you think otherwise but I want some! :p On the plus side I'm quite happy with my premium audio package, not perfect but pretty darn good.

leetheway 02-11-2011 10:49 AM

I agree the base is garbage. I had a 2008 E70 and the base in that one was manageable but I think BMW downgraded the base since.
I have the premium in the new car. It is better but not great definitely no where near my home system (and yes i still listen to cds and vinyl). Lexus and audi have much better system.

winterk 02-11-2011 11:26 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by leetheway (Post 5841576)
I agree the base is garbage. I had a 2008 E70 and the base in that one was manageable but I think BMW downgraded the base since.
I have the premium in the new car. It is better but not great definitely no where near my home system (and yes i still listen to cds and vinyl). Lexus and audi have much better system.

Agreed, a car will never match a home system though. It's hard to optimally place the speakers with all the seats, curves, and shapes that are in a car without having some of the signals blocked. Plus your speaker size is more limited.

onefish2 02-11-2011 02:49 PM

One more time... Its a good car stereo. Its in your car. Not in your living room.

I did not say it was great. I said it was good. And its far from crap. Could it be better? Sure. Should there be a better sound systems in a 60k car? Yes.

The point of my post was that the base stereo is OK and I do not think its necessary to spend another $1200 for the premium system. I am glad that I did not spend the extra money.

The other point was how are you guys determining that the base stereo sucks? What is your source FM? Sirius? a iPod? All of those sources are crap to begin with. I think sat radio is much worse sounding than even a 128k mp3. So please do not say you are making you determination based on listening to those sources.

I have a 2009 MINI Cooper. Now that IS a crap stereo.

Aqua Bliss 02-11-2011 03:10 PM

The base stereo sucks and I'm far from an Audiophile. It sounds like the music is being piped in with 2 cans and a string from my house to my car. Listen to any stereo in any other new car (even Honda/Toyota/Hyundai) they all sound 10x better than x5 crappy base stereo.

samsonitep 02-11-2011 04:15 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Aqua Bliss (Post 5842177)
The base stereo sucks and I'm far from an Audiophile. It sounds like the music is being piped in with 2 cans and a string from my house to my car. Listen to any stereo in any other new car (even Honda/Toyota/Hyundai) they all sound 10x better than x5 crappy base stereo.

lol...

THe premium sound system is "weak sauce" too...look at the specs does not even compare to a base in the range rover.

I went back to some 3 series that had Harmon Kardon speakers as their base WTF happened?


Just sad that when listening to howard stern his voice is not crisp...the base system always make it seem as if I need to turn up the volume but when I do it just hurts my ears.

Jim E. 02-11-2011 04:32 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by onefish2 (Post 5842126)
One more time... Its a good car stereo. Its in your car. Not in your living room.

I did not say it was great. I said it was good. And its far from crap. Could it be better? Sure. Should there be a better sound systems in a 60k car? Yes.

The point of my post was that the base stereo is OK and I do not think its necessary to spend another $1200 for the premium system. I am glad that I did not spend the extra money.

The other point was how are you guys determining that the base stereo sucks? What is your source FM? Sirius? a iPod? All of those sources are crap to begin with. I think sat radio is much worse sounding than even a 128k mp3. So please do not say you are making you determination based on listening to those sources.

I have a 2009 MINI Cooper. Now that IS a crap stereo.

I have an idea. When the weather is nicer, let's all meet up in the NY/NJ area and run a comparison. I'm being serious btw. Sort of like a blind taste test using the same source for music.

Btw, my primary listening source is a usb hard drive with all cd's burned in WMA Lossless. Not that I don't listen to other sources but a 240 gig hard drive can hold quite a bit - even lossless. ;)

pfbz 02-11-2011 04:34 PM

So to summarize....

The Base stereo is somewhere between crap and just fine,
while the Premium stereo is somewhere between weak sauce and pretty darn good.

Glad we cleared that up!


PS: Running boards suck on an X5... :rofl:

ard 02-11-2011 04:38 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Jim E. (Post 5842319)
I have an idea.

I have an idea:

Anyone buying an X5, LISTEN TO THE STEREO when making your ordering decision. Simple.

Arguing about sound quality is like arguing about girlfriends. Who knows what floats ones aural boat.

A

PS Agree on running boards! ;)

Jim E. 02-11-2011 04:44 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by pfbz (Post 5842322)
So to summarize....

The Base stereo is somewhere between crap and just fine,
while the Premium stereo is somewhere between weak sauce and pretty darn good.

Glad we cleared that up!


PS: Running boards suck on an X5... :rofl:

Wait, why are you leaving out the BMW Individual Sound system (aka: EPS)? :)

Jim E. 02-11-2011 04:46 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ard (Post 5842335)
I have an idea:

Anyone buying an X5, LISTEN TO THE STEREO when making your ordering decision. Simple.

Arguing about sound quality is like arguing about girlfriends. Who knows what floats ones aural boat.

A

PS Agree on running boards! ;)

I didn't know we were arguing. I'd better get in arguing mode. ;)

pfbz 02-11-2011 05:05 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ard (Post 5842335)
I have an idea:
Anyone buying an X5, LISTEN TO THE STEREO when making your ordering decision. Simple.

Around here, trying to finalize options by checking out dealer inventory is useless...

If your lucky, they have one or two X5's on the lot, usually configured pretty much identically.

Want to check out Multi-contour seats? Good luck! Curious about Nappa leather and dash? Not going to happen! Sport seats? Hah!

Oh, and no premium sound either. If your lucky, you can get a peak at two or three different exterior color options.

ard 02-11-2011 05:55 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Jim E. (Post 5842353)
I didn't know we were arguing. I'd better get in arguing mode. ;)

Not arguing bud, just using some alliteration from your post...:thumbup:

ard 02-11-2011 05:59 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by pfbz (Post 5842396)
Around here, trying to finalize options by checking out dealer inventory is useless...

If your lucky, they have one or two X5's on the lot, usually configured pretty much identically.

Want to check out Multi-contour seats? Good luck! Curious about Nappa leather and dash? Not going to happen! Sport seats? Hah!

Oh, and no premium sound either. If your lucky, you can get a peak at two or three different exterior color options.

I'm just saying, you are spending $65k, you'd think that over the course of the few weeks it takes to finalize a deal, a buyer could find a car somewhere to make a decision. I'm just talking sound... I do agree it is a challenge. Actually one very hard thing to test is adaptive drive. NO DEALER WILL ORDER THIS for a 'lot sale'.

samsonitep 02-11-2011 06:48 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by pfbz (Post 5842322)
So to summarize....

The Base stereo is somewhere between crap and just fine,
while the Premium stereo is somewhere between weak sauce and pretty darn good.

Glad we cleared that up!


PS: Running boards suck on an X5... :rofl:

Running board make it look decent....roof rails suck..

335i 02-11-2011 09:35 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by onefish2 (Post 5840081)
Just picked up a X5 35i Premium today. I will keep this short and sweet. I am am music fanatic. I have over 1500 CDs, 65,000 songs in iTunes, been to over 100 concerts, 10+ ipods over the years, 3 stereos in my house and iPod docks all over my house too. I am a music perfectionist. Maybe even an audiophile.

The standard stereo in the X5 is just fine. If you listen to mp3s, Sirius or FM radio... well all of those are poor sources to begin with. If you only listen to CDs while the car is parked then maybe, just maybe you won't like the stereo.

Its a good car stereo. Its in your car. Not in your living room.

I'm curious, what kind of "audiophile" system do you run in your house? B&W? Martin Logan? Any vinyl?

The base stereo, for a 65K vehicle, is barely adequate. The premium 35i stereo is upgraded from the base, but is not the "premium audio". I think there are probably other systems that sound worse - but I'd like to think the system can be improved for the amount of $$ we pay, especially those who are paying the $2K for the "premium" audio.

winterk 02-11-2011 11:48 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by pfbz (Post 5842322)
So to summarize....

The Base stereo is somewhere between crap and just fine,
while the Premium stereo is somewhere between weak sauce and pretty darn good.

Glad we cleared that up!


PS: Running boards suck on an X5... :rofl:

Oh now you had to bring running boards into it...now it's on! :violent: LOVE the running boards, they're hot stuff, plus they save your X5 from door dings from cars. They stick out just enough from the door trim so they hit the running boards first (no protection from trucks though). Glad we cleared that up. :D

03BMW330 02-12-2011 06:44 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by pfbz (Post 5842396)
Around here, trying to finalize options by checking out dealer inventory is useless...

If your lucky, they have one or two X5's on the lot, usually configured pretty much identically.

Want to check out Multi-contour seats? Good luck! Curious about Nappa leather and dash? Not going to happen! Sport seats? Hah!

Oh, and no premium sound either. If your lucky, you can get a peak at two or three different exterior color options.

+1, my dealer didn't have diesel for me to drive and all the cars in showroom were "Dead" battery not charged :thumbdwn: Thay had one demo unit but someone was drivin it ....

BMW lack of oversight is amazing (My local grocery store spend more time rearranging Frito Lay around the store than BMW selling 70K + cars)

I specifically ordered premium sound because everybody was saying how bad stock was ... :mad: oh well at least I didn't get running boards :D


All times are GMT -7. The time now is 10:29 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2014, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.
© 2001-2011 performanceIX, Inc. All Rights Reserved .: guidelines .:. privacy .:. terms