Bimmerfest - BMW Forums

Bimmerfest - BMW Forums (http://www.bimmerfest.com/forums/index.php)
-   F10 / F11 (2011 - Current) (http://www.bimmerfest.com/forums/forumdisplay.php?f=141)
-   -   I Test Drove M5 (http://www.bimmerfest.com/forums/showthread.php?t=672791)

bodonx 01-27-2013 09:32 PM

I Test Drove M5
 
I test drove M5 yesterday. My current ride is 535i with ACS springs.

This is my mini review. This is only my opinion and not trying to offend M5 owners.

POSITIVE (From best to good)
  1. DCT is the best part of M5 over regular F10. It's very quick yet smooth. Even if you try, you cannot make it jerk. It's light years ahead of our 8AT.
  2. Suspension: M5 suspension feels very stable and solid (not floaty) compared to my ACS equipped F10. There's no body roll. The ride is actually better. I think it's due to PSS tires are much more comfortable than RFT. Come on BMW, why do you need to install RFT?
  3. Power: Although most people love the power. For me, having big power on the straight line does not mean that important for me. This is like AMG in the past. Just big power, not much excitement. Past legendary M cars were about delivering driving experience no other couldn't mimic.

NEGATIVE (from most critical to least critical)

  1. The steering is dead. Even older non-M 5-series had more feel than this one. Changing the steering setting only makes it heavier. Sometimes there's fake feel coming from the steering which feels more like random vibration. I don't get why BMW messed it up when they have achieved a steering perfection in E39/E30/E36/E46 era.
  2. Weight: even with great handling, you can feel the car weight. You won't be able to feel the tossable feel that older M5 had over its competitors
  3. Interior: the one I drove doesn't have full leather. It makes the car feel the same as regular 5-series. I think BMW has oversold "M" brand with msport on all cars. Older M userd to have special interior pieces that made them special such as steering wheel, special stitching, M logos, etc.

Verdict:

If you MUST have one car, M5 is the best choice. It is very comfortable as family/business car, it is pretty excited as a "sport" car.

For $100k, I'd prefer to get 528 and used M3. Current M3 gives 9 out of 10 driving excitement. Whereas F10 M5 only give 7 out 10 driving excitement. It's hard to explain what's missing. Current F10 M5 does not give me goose bumps like when I drove older M cars (even with less power < 400 hp).

bm323 01-27-2013 11:07 PM

hi, not offending you either :) how long did you test drive the M5 and on what roads? Did/do you own a E60 M5?

A reviewer with a different perspective :D http://f10.m5post.com/forums/showpos...21&postcount=1

ps one more http://www.m5board.com/vbulletin/f10...ml#post2605761

PeterC4 01-28-2013 03:29 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by bodonx (Post 7342510)
I test drove M5 yesterday. My current ride is 535i with ACS springs.

  1. The steering is dead. Even older non-M 5-series had more feel than this one. Changing the steering setting only makes it heavier. Sometimes there's fake feel coming from the steering which feels more like random vibration.

I have this sensation on my 535xi MSport. It is very subtle and not like a wheel is out of balance but it is like simulated road feel but it is a very very high frequency vibe in the steering wheel, like lane assist is barely on. I think it is just part of the drivetrain.

K-A 01-28-2013 03:53 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by PeterC4 (Post 7342725)
I have this sensation on my 535xi MSport. It is very subtle and not like a wheel is out of balance but it is like simulated road feel but it is a very very high frequency vibe in the steering wheel, like lane assist is barely on. I think it is just part of the drivetrain.

I've felt a vibration in my steering wheel as well, though sometimes at idle. It's random enough for me to have thought it would be some weird purposeful sensation BMW engineered into it, to simulate some kind of "feel", though that wouldn't make sense as it was at idle....

demas 01-28-2013 05:00 AM

Thanks for the review

Quote:

Originally Posted by bodonx (Post 7342510)
I don't get why BMW messed it up when they have achieved a steering perfection in E39...

curious, have you driven the E39 M5? The recirculating ball setup had always been the Achilles heel on that car - Rack & Pinion would have made it 10 out of 10.

Needsdecaf 01-28-2013 06:44 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by bm323 (Post 7342613)
hi, not offending you either :) how long did you test drive the M5 and on what roads? Did/do you own a E60 M5?

A reviewer with a different perspective :D http://f10.m5post.com/forums/showpos...21&postcount=1

ps one more http://www.m5board.com/vbulletin/f10...ml#post2605761

Man, you really cannot stand to hear anything bad about BMW can you? What does it matter if he's owned / driven an E60 M5? Is he not entitled to his opinion?

AggieKnight 01-28-2013 06:56 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by bm323 (Post 7342613)
hi, not offending you either :) how long did you test drive the M5 and on what roads? Did/do you own a E60 M5?

I'm not sure how relevant other reviews are to this guys or whether he owned an older M5. Doesn't add much to the conversation and his points (particularly the steering) are things I've seen echo'd repeatedly.

OP,

Thanks for your review. Very much enjoyed reading it.

elitex 01-28-2013 07:58 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by bodonx (Post 7342510)
I test drove M5 yesterday. My current ride is 535i with ACS springs.

This is my mini review. This is only my opinion and not trying to offend M5 owners.

POSITIVE (From best to good)
  1. DCT is the best part of M5 over regular F10. It's very quick yet smooth. Even if you try, you cannot make it jerk. It's light years ahead of our 8AT.
  2. Suspension: M5 suspension feels very stable and solid (not floaty) compared to my ACS equipped F10. There's no body roll. The ride is actually better. I think it's due to PSS tires are much more comfortable than RFT. Come on BMW, why do you need to install RFT?
  3. Power: Although most people love the power. For me, having big power on the straight line does not mean that important for me. This is like AMG in the past. Just big power, not much excitement. Past legendary M cars were about delivering driving experience no other couldn't mimic.

NEGATIVE (from most critical to least critical)

  1. The steering is dead. Even older non-M 5-series had more feel than this one. Changing the steering setting only makes it heavier. Sometimes there's fake feel coming from the steering which feels more like random vibration. I don't get why BMW messed it up when they have achieved a steering perfection in E39/E30/E36/E46 era.
  2. Weight: even with great handling, you can feel the car weight. You won't be able to feel the tossable feel that older M5 had over its competitors
  3. Interior: the one I drove doesn't have full leather. It makes the car feel the same as regular 5-series. I think BMW has oversold "M" brand with msport on all cars. Older M userd to have special interior pieces that made them special such as steering wheel, special stitching, M logos, etc.

Verdict:

If you MUST have one car, M5 is the best choice. It is very comfortable as family/business car, it is pretty excited as a "sport" car.

For $100k, I'd prefer to get 528 and used M3. Current M3 gives 9 out of 10 driving excitement. Whereas F10 M5 only give 7 out 10 driving excitement. It's hard to explain what's missing. Current F10 M5 does not give me goose bumps like when I drove older M cars (even with less power < 400 hp).

I somewhat agree with your assessment. Putting the Engine and Transmission aside, this is what 550I M-Sport should feel like, not an M5. I was thinking about getting an M5 but I may go with an M3, and buy a SUV as our second car.

bodonx 01-28-2013 07:59 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by bm323 (Post 7342613)
hi, not offending you either :) how long did you test drive the M5 and on what roads? Did/do you own a E60 M5?

A reviewer with a different perspective :D http://f10.m5post.com/forums/showpos...21&postcount=1

ps one more http://www.m5board.com/vbulletin/f10...ml#post2605761

I'm not trying to approve or disapprove anything. I already read all the reviews a long time ago.

I'm just giving my two cents.

dunderhi 01-28-2013 08:01 AM

Thanks for the review. Some guys love the M5 and some guys don't, unfortunately many of the guys who love the car just won't accept that others don't love it. It's hilarious that they challenge how long the test drive was after they dismiss other cars after short test drives. Either it clicks or it doesn't.

Personally, after a disappointing test drive of the M6, I told the CA not to brother with getting the M5 ready. :(

bodonx 01-28-2013 08:05 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by demas (Post 7342785)
Thanks for the review



curious, have you driven the E39 M5? The recirculating ball setup had always been the Achilles heel on that car - Rack & Pinion would have made it 10 out of 10.

I already drove non-M E39, E46 M3, E60 M5, E92 M3. Among all of these I like E46 M3 steering feel the best. However, it is too heavy for parking sometimes.

A lot of my friends said E36 M3 has better steering than all. But, I never tried it myself.

PeterC4 01-28-2013 08:31 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by K-A (Post 7342738)
I've felt a vibration in my steering wheel as well, though sometimes at idle. It's random enough for me to have thought it would be some weird purposeful sensation BMW engineered into it, to simulate some kind of "feel", though that wouldn't make sense as it was at idle....

It's amazing what BMW would have us think....:dunno: or hope we think.

bodonx 01-28-2013 11:39 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by dunderhi (Post 7343074)
Thanks for the review. Some guys love the M5 and some guys don't, unfortunately many of the guys who love the car just won't accept that others don't love it. It's hilarious that they challenge how long the test drive was after they dismiss other cars after short test drives. Either it clicks or it doesn't.

Personally, after a disappointing test drive of the M6, I told the CA not to brother with getting the M5 ready. :(

With your Dinan-BBS-PSS-tuned 550i beast, I can imagine you will not be impressed with M5/M6 at all. :)

solstice 01-28-2013 03:22 PM

Sounds like our preferences and how we experience cars are very similar. My verdict after a test drive is close although mine is slightly harsher, likely due to showing up and leaving in an M3. And if you don't need the extra space there is imo no need for two cars if you buy an M3, it's not an uncomfortable car.

ausdude 01-28-2013 04:16 PM

I know what you mean about goose bumps. My previous car was a CL600 and when you took of, or took corners really fast my foot would shake and I would get goose bumps. I havent had this feeling in my 550. Having said that, I do like the 550i but the excitement isnt the same

SuperTerp 01-28-2013 04:56 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by bodonx (Post 7342510)

For $100k, I'd prefer to get 528 and used M3. Current M3 gives 9 out of 10 driving excitement. Whereas F10 M5 only give 7 out 10 driving excitement. It's hard to explain what's missing. Current F10 M5 does not give me goose bumps like when I drove older M cars (even with less power < 400 hp).

why not just get an m3+ ESS VT2-650 :p

Stealth8 01-28-2013 05:19 PM

Your impressions (which I share for the most part) were one of the main reasons I went for a 550i M-Sport with Dinan S2 and some 20" HRE P40SCs. There is a Blue F10 M5 in our parking structure at work and it looks great, but I am not interested in switching--especially for the extra $30k+. The M5 is too heavy and not sporty enough. The fact that at least one (2?) comparo has picked the E63 over the F10 M5 was also not a good sign.

ausdude 01-28-2013 06:27 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Stealth8 (Post 7344370)
Your impressions (which I share for the most part) were one of the main reasons I went for a 550i M-Sport with Dinan S2 and some 20" HRE P40SCs. There is a Blue F10 M5 in our parking structure at work and it looks great, but I am not interested in switching--especially for the extra $30k+. The M5 is too heavy and not sporty enough. The fact that at least one (2?) comparo has picked the E63 over the F10 M5 was also not a good sign.

I havent gotten the Dinan Stage 2 on my 550... yet. Should go ahead and do it? My biggest set back is the fuel consumption. I just got rid of a V12 and the gas difference is huge

bodonx 01-28-2013 06:28 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by SuperTerp (Post 7344316)
why not just get an m3+ ESS VT2-650 :p

Hehhehe

M5 has way more than enough power. If it were up to me, I would be gladly trade 100hp less with better steering or 400 lbs weight reduction.

bodonx 01-28-2013 06:34 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Stealth8 (Post 7344370)
Your impressions (which I share for the most part) were one of the main reasons I went for a 550i M-Sport with Dinan S2 and some 20" HRE P40SCs. There is a Blue F10 M5 in our parking structure at work and it looks great, but I am not interested in switching--especially for the extra $30k+. The M5 is too heavy and not sporty enough. The fact that at least one (2?) comparo has picked the E63 over the F10 M5 was also not a good sign.

If you switch your exhaust with M5 full exhaust (like in other thread), you will get the same experience as M5 and save $25k ;)

bm323 01-28-2013 07:39 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Needsdecaf (Post 7342917)
Man, you really cannot stand to hear anything bad about BMW can you? What does it matter if he's owned / driven an E60 M5? Is he not entitled to his opinion?

:) sure it matters, he's comparing with the E60 M5 (amongst others) was he not?? And of course, he's entitled to his opinion ... you mean you are regulating and one is not entitled to query the basis of his opinion??

bm323 01-28-2013 07:41 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by K-A (Post 7342738)
I've felt a vibration in my steering wheel as well, though sometimes at idle. It's random enough for me to have thought it would be some weird purposeful sensation BMW engineered into it, to simulate some kind of "feel", though that wouldn't make sense as it was at idle....

There is no vibration when mine is at idle :) and the "vibration" varies with the road :D

bm323 01-28-2013 07:45 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by dunderhi (Post 7343074)
Thanks for the review. Some guys love the M5 and some guys don't, unfortunately many of the guys who love the car just won't accept that others don't love it. It's hilarious that they challenge how long the test drive was after they dismiss other cars after short test drives. Either it clicks or it doesn't.

Personally, after a disappointing test drive of the M6, I told the CA not to brother with getting the M5 ready. :(

One forummer mentioned that the shop would only permit him to test drive a M5 going around the block ... and if I recall correctly, your test drive of the M6 was disappointing for very different reasons :)

bm323 01-28-2013 07:52 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by bodonx (Post 7344607)
If you switch your exhaust with M5 full exhaust (like in other thread), you will get the same experience as M5 and save $25k ;)

Brilliant post, presumably you have the PSS, and your 535i handles like the M5 :D

Quote:

Originally Posted by bodonx (Post 7342510)
[*]DCT is the best part of M5 over regular F10. It's very quick yet smooth. Even if you try, you cannot make it jerk. It's light years ahead of our 8AT.[*]Suspension: M5 suspension feels very stable and solid (not floaty) compared to my ACS equipped F10. There's no body roll. The ride is actually better. I think it's due to PSS tires are much more comfortable than RFT. Come on BMW, why do you need to install RFT?


Needsdecaf 01-28-2013 08:13 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by bm323 (Post 7344826)
:) sure it matters, he's comparing with the E60 M5 (amongst others) was he not?? And of course, he's entitled to his opinion ... you mean you are regulating and one is not entitled to query the basis of his opinion??

No, simply that pretty much any time someone posts a negative review of the F10, you pretty much tell them they're an idiot.

Maybe it's a cultural thing, but that's the way you come across. You certainly don't give the impression of respecting other's opinions when they're negative.


All times are GMT -7. The time now is 03:33 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2014, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.
© 2001-2011 performanceIX, Inc. All Rights Reserved .: guidelines .:. privacy .:. terms