Is that the car at McKenna BMW? Seems very similar to the one they have listed. I honestly wouldn't pay more than $51K for it given what the Manheim auctions look like right now.
I'm about to pull the trigger on a similar car with 17K, non-CPO for $47K out the door. Talked to my service rep and he said that an EasyCare warranty will set me back $4K which still puts me ahead over $3K (sales tax).
Whatever you decide, good luck to you!!
2013 Silverstone///M5/Executive Package/B&O/20" Wheels/DCT/Black Interior
2012 Black Sapphire 740i/ M-Sport/Black Interior
2013 Imperial Blue///M5/Executive Package/20" Wheels/DCT/Sakhir Orange Interior
2012 Mineral White///M3 Coupe/Competition Package/DCT/Fox Red Interior
2008 Titanium Silver 650i Coupe/Sports Package/Nav/Logic 7/HUD/Black Interior
2006 Stratus Gray 650i Coupe/Sports Package/Nav/Logic 7/Cream Interior