View Single Post
Old 12-14-2011, 11:19 AM
rtgirard's Avatar
rtgirard rtgirard is offline
Location: Upstate, New York
Join Date: Feb 2010
Posts: 615
Mein Auto: 2013 335xi
Ok... i just read through this thread and I'm convinced that Terri's problem is one of two things:

1 - The battery is defective


2 - There is a problem with the car

My wife has virtually the same driving pattern as you do, Terri. Our 328 has never once been hooked up to a trickle charger and frequently goes weeks without being driven outside a 5 mile radius, and we've never seen a battery discharge warning (if my wife had experienced this, believe me, she would have let me know).

I realize this is not necessarily a cheap answer, but if you can, I'd suggest you take it to an independent BMW shop and ask them to test the battery. If it fails, then great... you've got an answer. If it passes, then I'd pay the Indy for his/her time and head back to the dealer. There's either a module that's not shutting down and causing a drain, OR, the original battery registration is incorrect and the car isn't charging the battery correctly while you're driving.

It's very possible I've missed a post when someone has ruled these possibilities out, but I really think your driving pattern isn't to blame. We've been putting < 200/week on our car for almost 24 months without a problem.

Good luck!
F30 335xi - Ordered on 9/5/2012... Delivered 10/29/2012

BMWCCA# 457109
Reply With Quote