Thanks for pushing on this Sean. I hope we can crack it.
Update on my situation is I had the dealer check the TPMS and valve stems in case the tire shop messed with them. They said I have the original OEM TPMS and metal valve stems.
2013 ///M5 Individual Monte Carlo Blue, Platinum Full Individual Merino, Platinum Alcantara, Piano Black, Exec Pkg, Drivers assistance pkg, Bang and Olufsen, 20" wheels, Eisenmann Sport, STIR+, LI Quad HP