I feel your pain. WV is crawling with deer also and I tagged one a couple of years back in my Toyota. It is such a pain to deal with the repair and then you have an accident on the history. Good luck and make them fix it properly. I had to move mine from the first garage after a few days due to them trying to go on the cheap with the repairs. Luckily my insurance agent took my side and wound up taking them off his preferred list.
So far I have engaged the antilock brakes a couple of times in the Bimmer but luckily haven't hit another one yet.
94 318I, 96 740IL, 97 528I, 07 335I