Same thing happened to me. Indy mechanic told me BMW doesn't replace rotors on the "maint plan" but will recommend it if you are paying full price. He said it should be criminal not to replace rotors every time you do the pads.
Originally Posted by BLT
I just took our car in for it's final checkup maintenance under the 4-year warrantee. They replaced the brake pads and sensors but did not replace the rotor because they were within specifications.
Certainly does not leave a favorable impression of BMW, continuously cutting corners with new gimmicks like run flats, oil changes, and now shoddy brake jobs.
1993 325i - gone!
1997 328i - gone!