UPDATE- I spoke with Otto's BMW in West Chester PA who sold me the car. I have an appointment on Friday (with loaner car) me to drop off the car and they'll fix whatever the issue it is. They said it's a regular thing and should only take a few hours to fix. I can't wait to see what the car feels like when I get her back afterward!
2008 BMW 535xi (6-speed manual) Alpine white/ Dakota black/ Anthracite bamboo. Premium/Cold/Sport Packages, L7, Nav, 76,000 miles.