That Cuddly Kitty Is Deadlier Than You Think

some of my friends keep colonies of strays alive at a park nearby.
There probably aren't too many birds there.

some of the comments are great...

That Cuddly Kitty Is Deadlier Than You Think


For all the adorable images of cats that play the piano, flush the toilet, mew melodiously and find their way back home over hundreds of miles, scientists have identified a shocking new truth: cats are far deadlier than anyone realized.

In a report that scaled up local surveys and pilot studies to national dimensions, scientists from the Smithsonian Conservation Biology Institute and the Fish and Wildlife Service estimated that domestic cats in the United States - both the pet Fluffies that spend part of the day outdoors and the unnamed strays and ferals that never leave it - kill a median of 2.4 billion birds and 12.3 billion mammals a year, most of them native mammals like shrews, chipmunks and voles rather than introduced pests like the Norway rat.

The estimated kill rates are two to four times higher than mortality figures previously bandied about, and position the domestic cat as one of the single greatest human-linked threats to wildlife in the nation. More birds and mammals die at the mouths of cats, the report said, than from automobile strikes, pesticides and poisons, collisions with skyscrapers and windmills and other so-called anthropogenic causes.

Peter Marra of the Smithsonian Conservation Biology Institute and an author of the report, said the mortality figures that emerge from the new model "are shockingly high."

"When we ran the model, we didn't know what to expect," said Dr. Marra, who performed the analysis with his colleague, Scott R. Loss, and Tom Will of the Fish and Wildlife Service. "We were absolutely stunned by the results." The study appeared Tuesday in the journal Nature Communications.

The findings are the first serious estimate of just how much wildlife America's vast population of free-roaming domestic cats manages to kill each year.

"We've been discussing this problem of cats and wildlife for years and years, and now we finally have some good science to start nailing down the numbers," said George H. Fenwick, the president and chief executive of the American Bird Conservancy. "This is a great leap forward over the quality of research we had before."

In devising their mathematical model, the researchers systematically sifted through the existing scientific literature on cat-wildlife interactions, eliminated studies in which the sample size was too small or the results too extreme, and then extracted and standardized the findings from the 21 most rigorous studies. The results admittedly come with wide ranges and uncertainties.

Nevertheless, the new report is likely to fuel the sometimes vitriolic debate between environmentalists who see free-roaming domestic cats as an invasive species - super predators whose numbers are growing globally even as the songbirds and many other animals the cats prey on are in decline - and animal welfare advocates who are appalled by the millions of unwanted cats (and dogs) euthanized in animal shelters each year.

All concur that pet cats should not be allowed to prowl around the neighborhood at will, any more than should a pet dog, horse or potbellied pig, and that cat owners who insist their felines "deserve" a bit of freedom are being irresponsible and ultimately not very cat friendly. Through recent projects like Kitty Cams at the University of Georgia, in which cameras are attached to the collars of indoor–outdoor pet cats to track their activities, not only have cats been filmed preying on cardinals, frogs and field mice, they've been shown lapping up antifreeze and sewer sludge, dodging under moving cars and sparring violently with much bigger dogs.

"We've put a lot of effort into trying to educate people that they should not let their cats outside, that it's bad for the cats and can shorten the cats' lives," said Danielle Bays, the manager of the community cat programs at the Washington Humane Society.

Yet the new study estimates that free-roaming pets account for only about 29 percent of the birds and 11 percent of the mammals killed by domestic cats each year, and the real problem arises over how to manage the 80 million or so stray or feral cats that commit the bulk of the wildlife slaughter.

The Washington Humane Society and many other animal welfare organizations support the use of increasingly popular trap-neuter-return programs, in which unowned cats are caught, vaccinated, spayed and, if no home can be found for them, returned to the outdoor colony from which they came. Proponents see this approach as a humane alternative to large-scale euthanasia, and they insist that a colony of neutered cats can't reproduce and thus will eventually disappear.

Conservationists say that, far from diminishing the population of unowned cats, trap and release programs may be making it worse, by encouraging people to abandon their pets to outdoor colonies that volunteers often keep lovingly fed.

"The number of free roaming cats is definitively growing," Dr. Fenwick of the bird conservancy said. "It's estimated that there are now more than 500 TNR colonies in Austin alone."

They are colonies of subsidized predators, he said, able to survive in far greater concentrations than do wild carnivores by dint of their people-pleasing appeal. "They're not like coyotes, having to make their way in the world," he said.

Yet even fed cats are profoundly tuned to the hunt, and when they see something flutter, they can't help but move in for the kill. Dr. Fenwick argues that far more effort should be put into animal adoption. "For the great majority of healthy cats," he said, "homes can be found." Any outdoor colonies that remain should be enclosed, he said. "Cats don't need to wander hundred of miles to be happy," he said.

1077 Comments

Rex the wonder dog Backyard
As I was saying to my canine brethren at the park today, is anyone really surprised by this story? None of us dogs that get the NYTimes are! And yes, we can also read.

Fluffy may act all soft and innocent, but under that furry exterior beats the heart of a psychopath. For millennia, we've been blamed for knocking over kitchen garbage, barking, chewing up old shoes and the like when the real culprit was Mitzy. Catch-neuter-and-release? I think not! Catch-and-make-throw-rugs-out-of-their-little-carcasses is what I say.

I've got an itch, sorry, gotta go.

I feel partially responsible for these statistics. Ever since I put one of our cats outside due to poor indoor behavior, the rat/mice/bird population is making a wide berth around our backyard.

(She killed a bunny once. I did feel a little bad about that... )

there are feral cats in the woods behind our house. i keep them away from the bird bath and bird feeders with battery powered motion activated lights and sound makers. seems to work okay. i don't mind them killing and eating mice, voles and ground squirrels. not the birds, though. i imagine the racoons, opossums, the occasional coyote and fox, and the cats have fun at night looking out for each other.

Originally Posted by noego

there are feral cats in the woods behind our house. i keep them away from the bird bath and bird feeders with battery powered motion activated lights and sound makers. seems to work okay. i don't mind them killing and eating mice, voles and ground squirrels. not the birds, though. i imagine the racoons, opossums, the occasional coyote and fox, and the cats have fun at night looking out for each other.

Estimates are that cats kill 15% of the bird population.
Those small mammals occupy a niche in the ecosystem.

Of no small concern is also the health risks to your cat. Mine was outdoors nearly every day. She spent time under cars which leaked oil and carried it in on her paws which she then licked off. By the time I took her in (she was a stray) she had kidney disease. I suspect all that oil and radiator fluid didn't help and may have actually caused her kidney problems.

I know folks who put a lot of time into neuter and return and they also keep the cats fed.
Looks like there are consequences to these behaviors