First Impressions of BMW i3 EV

by Tim Jones on July 29, 2013, 6:36 pm
BMW i3 world premiere

BMW has taken a bold step in a new direction with the launch of the electric i3 today. With the i3 BMW took a clean slate approach to the design with a clear focus on it being "Born Electric". The i3 is driven by a rear mounted 170 horsepower electric motor that is powered by a 22 kWh battery pack stored in an aluminum Drive Module. Glued and bolted to the top of the Drive Module is a carbon fiber passenger compartment BMW has named the Life Module. This is the first mass produced carbon fiber vehicle to come off an assembly line and is just one of the many firsts the i3 boasts.

BMW i3 first impressions

The specs on the i3 are long and impressive; on paper it is a clearly a technical triumph. It packs a long list of new technology with many industry leading and industry first features. BMW also has spent countless hours ensuring that the driving dynamics they are known for are not lost while pursuing an alternative form of propulsion. Impressive features, check. Amazing technology and superb driving dynamics, check. The big question is what does the BMW i3 make you feel?

BMW i3 in person

To be blunt, for the 2.7 billion (or there about) dollars BMW has spent on the i program, I expected more. There aren't many angles the i3 looks good from and it photographs even worse. It does look better in person than in pictures, but that leaves a lot of room for improvement. BMW has put its entire weight behind this program when they could have created a spin off brand as Mercedes has with the Smart Car. By putting the roundel on the i3, BMW is betting the rent money that this is going to succeed. To that end they've attempted to bring the key BMW design elements to the i3 including the kidney grills and Hofmeister kink.

BMW i3 with glued on heritage

This is where BMW has failed with the i3. They have tried to bringing their classic design elements to a next generation idea. Simply put, you cannot glue on heritage. The kidney grills, which are air intakes on combustion powered BMWs, are adorned on the front of the car like an afterthought. The i3 electric motor is in the rear so the grills serve no functional purpose and are closed off without the traditional vertical slats. The side and rear lines are better, with a door swage line and the Hofmeister kink nicely countering the strong back door window slant. The design of the rear works and looks good despite its tall boxy proportions.

At this point you're thinking, is the BMW i3 a 2.7 billion mistake by BMW? The answer is no, not even close. The i3, while not being the best looking car, is a game changer. The looks are not the focal point of the burgeoning EV market. The existing players in the market all have various kitschy, look at me design and the i3 fits right in. BMW knows their existing enthusiasts customer, the Bimmerfest reader, who lusts over 500 horsepower M cars aren't the target i3 buyer. The i3 is entirely new vehicle design for BMW and is going to bring an entirely new buyer to the brand.
bmw-i3-world-debut-on-location 1bmw-i3-world-debut-on-location 2bmw-i3-world-debut-on-location 3bmw-i3-world-debut-on-location 4bmw-i3-world-debut-on-location 5bmw-i3-world-debut-on-location 6bmw-i3-world-debut-on-location 7bmw-i3-world-debut-on-location 8bmw-i3-world-debut-on-location 9bmw-i3-world-debut-on-location 10bmw-i3-world-debut-on-location 11bmw-i3-world-debut-on-location 12

Leave a Comment

You must be a registered member to comment on stories. Please take a moment to register for your free account now. If you already have an account, log in using fields below.

6 responses to First Impressions of BMW i3 EV

E36 Phantom commented:
July 29, 2013, 7:05 pm

They absolutely should have spun it off to a sub brand, this completely dilutes their reputation and looks like garbage.

C:\>Sent from my 386 using MS-DOS__
GeoX750Li commented:
July 31, 2013, 12:02 am

Oh boy, what mess this is.
kestrelroadie commented:
July 31, 2013, 2:12 am

This car will be bought by Europeans who can't drive their ICE into the major city centers without paying a carbon tax/fee and probably will eventually be banned altogether at some point in places like London and Paris. The US maket will be mostly the hipsters and the techno geeks or BMW fanboys which still should be a decent niumber. I expect most of these to be sold in the EU.
Andrew*Debbie commented:
July 31, 2013, 4:46 am

Originally Posted by kestrelroadie View Post
This car will be bought by Europeans who can't drive their ICE into the major city centers without paying a carbon tax/fee

The London Congestion Charge is 10 a day. For anyone driving into the congestion charge on a daily basis an EV is a no brainer.

At the moment that means settling for a Leaf or a Zoe. The i3 is going to do well in this niche.

On top of that there are substantial tax savings for company car drivers. The UK lease and support packages are targeted at company car drivers.

What I don't understand is why the i3 is so w i d e. It is obviously a city car.

I too think it could look better. The kidney grills look like an afterthought.
cblandin commented:
July 31, 2013, 11:19 pm

As a 2 time M car owner and current Chevy Volt owner, I had hoped for more from BMW on this one. Frankly, rear wheel drive and an attractive body would probably have been enough to have me swap back to a BMW after my Volts lease is up, but now Volt 2.0 will and the Audi A3 Etron are more interesting. Motor Trends pan of the i3's drive didn't help either.
pharding commented:
August 10, 2013, 11:39 am

It is hard to argue withe overwhelming sales success thus. In Europe they have over 200,000 orders. It is a game changer for BMW and the auto industry. I like it a lot. The only thing that I don't like are the stupid glue on ornamental, non functioning kidney grills. All together the car is uber spectacular.