Doubtful that the gas brand or 'grade' is the cause of that "10 mpg", imo...unless it was an unlucky tank(s) of bad gas. The best mpg I see, over nearly 11 years & 86k miles is from 89 grade, with occasional 91/93, but my mpg doesn't vary much. If improving from "~10 mpg" to what should be considerably higher/'normal' was as simple as a few tanks of big brand name 93, it would be like magic, lol!
Some things that come to mind: fuel filter clogged, tire pressures very low, MAF sensor, exhaust or intake cam sensors, fuel injectors, etc. Hard to hand out a specific diagnosis, imo...
Have you scanned for any codes?
My 50Cts...
GL, mD