BimmerFest BMW Forum banner

Car perceptions now and before. Your opinion, please

1564 Views 12 Replies 10 Participants Last post by  LJS330i
naturally i am generalizing and it's MHO, but I would say that currently the public perception is as follows:

German made cars have the reputation of having a soul, fun-to-drive, good handling

Japanese cars are reliabile (gas and go), and a good value, but not exciting

American cars are at best of average quality. there are some stand-outs, but on the whole below average in quality.


What was the perception during the 60's?

German cars: i have no idea

Japanese cars: i think they just started making cars. And the cars they did make were of low quality?? sort of like the history of Korean cars??

American cars: I think of muscle cars. was this their greatest era? were these cars considered the best?



During the 50's:

German cars: no idea

Japanese cars: i don't think they made cars yet.

American cars: muscle cars again?? just don't know.


so if someone out there who knows the history of cars or is a little older than me, please fill in the blanks.
See less See more
1 - 13 of 13 Posts
Magna said:

American cars: I think of muscle cars. was this their greatest era? were these cars considered the best?
Thats all I had growing up. My first three cars were in order.

1.) 1970 Dodge Charger (383ci)

2.) 1971 Pontiac GTO (400ci)

3.) 1969 Plymoth Road Runner (383ci)

All really fun cars. I still lust after a primo '69 Judge 4-spd Convertable!! :D
See less See more
American cars pretty much dominated the market before the '70s. They were actually pretty good. As of now, Ford is going to be a very interesting company to watch :) They have started to make a good cars again...
Definately, Ford is on the rise. This may sound odd, but ever since the 1996 Taurus released I have said that they will rise to the top in Detroit. The spirit of ambition in the car's development just told it all: they were ready to make some waves. The Focus shows how they can even make the Civic look like a poor design.
See less See more
Well, the American car companies, (Is Chrysler American?) don't really have a choice. They are getting hammered by competition in every part of the world, save their home market, (which they are slowly losing) and the UK (of which they have just a handhold).

It seems that finally it’s hitting them hard enough in the pocketbook for them to take notice, and gradually they are trying to be more globally competitive. I think it will be interesting to see what happens as they turn around. Is it too late? Can they do it fast enough?

They must build cars to be cars, not build cars to make money. Money is a necessary extra, but in the end, it is the product that matters most.

I think their current situation is like that of the US military's history. For much of the begining the USA had a very poorly outfited and trained army with obsolete weapons. It wasn't until the tragedies of war showed the failures of the situation that a decision was made to forever be the top power of the world to avoid the needless casuaties that were suffered. (Hence the always ongoing weapons programs today)

It's late, just a rant... :p
See less See more
Japanese cars were at best, an oddity during the 60's. They did not truly establish a foothold in America until the first gas crisis of 1973. During the 1970's, U.S. drivers in larger and larger numbers were exposed to well built, fun to drive, reliable and economical Japanese cars (eg. Toyota Corolla and Corona, Datsun 510 and 240Z, Honda Civic and Accord). It was the introduction of the Honda Accord in 1976 that was the turning point for the Japanese automobile industry in America. What Honda did was build the "perfect" American car for Americans, something the big three somehow forgot how to do.

German cars were not a significant factor in America during the 1960's. True, there were dedicated Porsche and Mercedes owners in the U.S. during that time, but the sales numbers were tiny. In the 1970's, Mercedes and Porsche became status symbols in the U.S., and that was the turning point for the success of German cars in America. If you are old enough to remember, the Mercedes 450SL was "the" car to own back then - if you drove an SL, people assumed you had made it. (Note: I personally detest people who drive cars for status purposes. I am simply relating the history of the industry here)

American cars ruled the world in the 50's and 60's. Most people will agree that those two decades were the pinacle for the American car industry. GM owned more than 50% of the American market - many people traded their cars in every year! American cars were (with some execeptions, of course) beautifully styled, powerful, fast, and well-built back then. As far as market share, those days are gone forever. But I wouldn't count the American companies out - they have vast resources, both financial and human, and they know that their backs are up against the wall. I have been involved in the car industry since 1984, and I am confident that GM and Ford will get their acts together and start producing competitive vehicles again.
See less See more
Unfortunately I think a lot of German cars are still perceived as yuppie-mobiles as a carry over from the 80's.
fuz said:
(Is Chrysler American?)
Chrysler was an American car company until Diamler-Benz bought them out (uhhhh, merged) a few years back. Now DiamlerChrysler is a German car company.
Dan:

Would you say that during the 50's and 60s and even Germans coveted American cars? It would make sense since Germany was just finishing rebuilding after WWII, and probably wasn't putting their best people/resources towards cars.

I ask friends when they travel what kind of cars people all over the world drive and the carmakers' reputation. It's interesting that all over the world, people think Germans make great cars and that Japan makes great value/reliable cars. The American reputation seems to be mixed. In some countries American cars are not desired simply because they're considered too big, not because of low quality. Talking to an Australian friend, she didn't have an opinion on American cars because she was so unfamiliar with them. American carmakers have no market at all in Australia.
See less See more
That's not exactly true that American carmakers have no market in Australia. GM of Austraila markets their cars there under the name Holden and there's one other name I forget. There are some American-market cars that are sold there under different names (but I can't remeber the models or the names). From what I understand,GM has a fairly large market share there.
See less See more
Magna said:
Dan:

Would you say that during the 50's and 60s and even Germans coveted American cars? It would make sense since Germany was just finishing rebuilding after WWII, and probably wasn't putting their best people/resources towards cars.

I ask friends when they travel what kind of cars people all over the world drive and the carmakers' reputation. It's interesting that all over the world, people think Germans make great cars and that Japan makes great value/reliable cars. The American reputation seems to be mixed. In some countries American cars are not desired simply because they're considered too big, not because of low quality. Talking to an Australian friend, she didn't have an opinion on American cars because she was so unfamiliar with them. American carmakers have no market at all in Australia.
Good question - Although I don't have first hand knowledge, I would think that certain American cars from the 50's and 60's, such as Cadillac (remember that Cadillac was the standard of the world back then - wow, have things changed!), Lincoln, Packard (in the early 50's), and the Corvette and Thunderbird were coveted automobiles all over the world back then. However, none of the big three were making an effort to export these cars into Europe, because they were selling all they could make here in the states during that time period.

By the way, Ford sells cars in Australia, and they have a significant presence there. Remember the Falcon? Ford still sells it down under!
See less See more
ah that explains it. i asked my friend using model names that exist in the US. perhaps American carmakers didn't want Australians to associate their cars with our cars??? whatever it is i am sure the marketing people have their reasons.
American cars...

American auto manufacturers make some of the best quality bodies in the world. US car bodies are way better that Japanese and equal or better than that of the Germans. The stamping techniques and qaulity of steel used make all the difference.

Just my .02
1 - 13 of 13 Posts
This is an older thread, you may not receive a response, and could be reviving an old thread. Please consider creating a new thread.
Top