BimmerFest BMW Forum banner

Does anyone have trouble speed shifting from 3rd to 4th?

1483 Views 6 Replies 4 Participants Last post by  Imola Ed
When I speed shift from 3rd to 4th sometimes I miss a shift and hit the spot between 2nd and 4th. Anybody else have this problem? In my A4 I never miss a shift. In the bimmer it is like 4th is not straight back, almost like it is tilted towards the passenger a bit.

Reading the tech articles on UUC webpage I noticed that they recommended changing your hand position after 2nd gear so I assume other people have this problem. Is this the best way to solve it?

thx
jeff
1 - 7 of 7 Posts
I've never really had trouble with it. I did switch to the technique demonstrated on the UUC page and it made driving a lot more fun.
I usually shift with my hand on the side of the knob, as opposed to in front of/on top of the knob. I have only mis-shifted once in this car, and that was a 1st -> 2nd. Damn shifter popped right out of 2nd because I didn't shift it fully. After a slight grind the drivetrain went "BOOOOM!" ... I almost sh~t myself on the spot. ;)

Oh and let's not forget the time Chris yanked the shift knob completely off whilst trying to do a 2nd-gear burn in Florida. :D

3rd -> 4th is actually one of the smoothest speed shifts I can do in this car. The gate setup + the lack of exagerated torque (like 1st and 2nd give the perception of) make it easier than any other combo IMO.
I used to yank the knob off going into second all the time. I got my dealer to replace the knob and all was well. Then I got a ROb Knob Magnum SS and all was better. ;)
I've never had any issues moving from 3 to 4th. It's the fastest throw for me when speed shifting.
I guess I am just retarded with the bimmer. Is my tranny shifted a bit;-)

I guess I will try the different hand position suggested by UUC.

thanks
jeff
Jeff_DML said:
I guess I am just retarded with the bimmer. Is my tranny shifted a bit;-)

I guess I will try the different hand position suggested by UUC.

thanks
jeff
I don't even do what UUC says. I just cup the shifter and pull it straight back.

EDIT: I lied! I noticed on the way home that I actually slightly backhand it into 4th. Well whaddaya know!
1 - 7 of 7 Posts
This is an older thread, you may not receive a response, and could be reviving an old thread. Please consider creating a new thread.
Top