Overall, I continue to obssessed with my 325ci. I have had a few problems, mostly with tires, the clutch, and a various other odd things. A buzz has cropped up in the passenger door, but that I think will be an easy fix. And, unfortunately, the clutch shudder has returned. If there is one thing that seriously dissapoints me about this car, it's the clutch. It's just plain lousy.
Is the car everything that I expected?? Yes - and no. I sometimes find myself having fond memories of my VW GTI VR6 (gasp!). While a Volkswagen, the GTI had some serious fun factor. By comparison, it was crude and unrefined, but in a bizarre way, that was part of its charm. Performance wise, the VR6 is the 325's equal, in terms of power and acceleration off the line and mid range. Top end is another story, as I've found the Bimmer can travel beyond 100mph with much more ease - and confidence. Where the BMW really shines is in the handling department. The handling just blows the VW away.
Then again, the VW costs $12,000 less. Is the BMW worth the price? I'm honestly not sure. The constant problems and service visits worry me. Initially, the VW had one major problem, but after that was fixed, it was completely problem free - and I beat on that car relentlessly. I've easily put more time, money and energy keeping this car than all my others combined, and I haven't owned it a year.
Are these cars over rated and over priced? I think so, because there is a growing number of cars that are closing - and even surpassing - the gap on BMW in terms of performance, quality and value. I've read reports by some that Audi may bump BMW off the #1 spot for performance luxury cars. Then there's Lexus and Infiniti close behind.
Does all this mean I dislike my BMW - absolutely not! My BMW is a terrific car, and has a feel like no other I've driven. And it is a true "drivers machine" and I expect to keep it for many years to come....until I jump in my Old Mans MB E430. Now THAT car is the benchmark!
