You haven't specified if the fender bender involved any of the the rear wheels.
In any case, yes, the rear should not stick out like that with 16" rims and no spacers.
Most likely a broken control arm or worse, a cracked rear carrier. Have the suspension professionally checked.
Any easier way to tell is to see if there is excess wear pattern on the tire aside from normal camber wear on the inside. That is if you've driven it much after this fender bender.
Take a pick from directly behind the car
The rear side of the car scraped a guard rail and I also took off the right side to check for any inconsistencies and all the control arms look to be okay.
is your tire normal but the fender really pushed in?
I'll take it to a mechanic and report back as to the conclusion of the problem. Thanks for the input
To cut a long story short I got into a little fender bender a short time ago. I have been slowly restoring my beloved E39 540i back to her prime. For some reason the rear drivers side wheel is bent outwards I took off the wheel and nothing seems to be damaged or bent. Is it possible that the hit knocked the wheel out of alignment or is my suspension damaged? Please help