BimmerFest BMW Forum banner

What's the worst car repair scam you've ever encountered?

274 Views 2 Replies 3 Participants Last post by  XChallengeRdr
There will always be mechanics who will bend the truth to line their pockets. They'd do everything from exaggerating minor issues to recommending expensive repairs and part replacements that you don't really need. If you've been ripped off by a mechanic, don't panic. Keep calm and follow these steps.

So what's the worst mechanic scam you've ever encountered, and how did you deal with it?
Hand Motor vehicle Automotive mirror Beard Gesture
1 - 3 of 3 Posts
I was getting my Chevy pick-up truck's tires flipped on the wheels (at their half-life of 35k miles) at a tire store/repair shop, to counter the uneven wear that couldn't be fixed by alignment.

Some guy brought his Buick in for a "check" before starting his family's vacation trip to Wally World the next day. The shop told him that his brake lines were corroded, and if they failed him and his family could DIE. They yanked the old lines off, maybe damaging them in the process. The problem was than the local Buick dealership or anybody else didn't stock new brake lines. That's because they never fail. That surface corrosion is there by design to protect the lines from structural corrosion.

So, the guy was stuck there with his car in pieces waiting for special-order parts that didn't need replacing in the first place.

After I spent $100 to have my tires flipped, the sales-Bubba tried to sell me a set of Coopers for more than a set of Michelins would cost.

I ended up getting 74k miles out of those original tires on my Chevy pick-up truck.

I never went back to that tire store/repair shop.

Back in the 1970's VW's had brake lines that really would corrode to the point of failure. Once DOT's NYTSA found out about it, they required VW to do a recall and replace the brake lines.
I broke off a stud changing the water pump on my wife's Gen II Explorer. The car had over 200k miles and I wasn't about to do a lot of work just to change the water pump. I was working on a master's and didn't have the time to change the motor for a remanufactured one, so I had a local shop do it. At the first attempt to pick it up I noticed that the fan shroud was missing and the windows no longer worked. After I took it home the second time, I noticed that some of the parts on the throttle body were missing fasteners so back it went, two or three more times. A couple of years later I'm still finding things loose under the hood. The list of problems is two pages long. When I gave them a bad review on Yelp, Yelp downgraded it for some reason, along with most of the other negative reviews.

The lesson is never trust Yelp.
1 - 3 of 3 Posts
Top