BMW Forum - BimmerFest BMW Forums banner

The Technician Career Choice.

604 views 3 replies 2 participants last post by  Hemorrhage  
#1 ·
I've maintained straight A's in college (aside from one B) as an automotive student. I actually WANT to learn. I WANT to be the best. So, I put forth the extra time and effort. I can definitely say that me and one other student are the top dogs of the class.
*Still am in college for automotive, by the way. I'm part of an apprentice program with my dealership.*

I like working on cars. I like modifying. I like doing big jobs and then having it run perfectly after. I like being able to say that "I" modified my car and didn't pay someone else to do it.

However...I feel like the profession is a bit of a joke.
Yes, it's hard. It's damn hard. But, I feel like techs don't have to be as good as they used to be. Instead of using a DMM to diagnose a charging system, you just put a machine on it and it tells you what's wrong. Seems like that's how it is for everything. I feel like we're just pawns of the engineers...which makes me feel degraded and less respectable.

A car comes in the shop.
Put the scan tool on it, go online, and see if there is a post about it so we can fix it.

7/10 times, the problem has already happened, and we can go in and just fix it. That's how I feel the profession is. Look up what's wrong, print the instructions, follow the instructions, and fix it. Anybody can follow instructions and fix something...

Flat-rate is a joke. Tell me...who is the better tech? The one that can fix anything? Or the guy that can pull 50 hours a week because he does new car preps and brake jobs all week?

I'd rather do the tranny, engine, and electrical work for a living, because that actually takes a brain to do. However, it doesn't pay **** because it's usually warranty. So, why would I want to do that?

It's honestly stupid.

I don't know. Hoping someone with more experience can change my insight on stuff and make me not regret my career...especially since I'm $10k in the hole to it (from buying tools).

I've only been in this career for about 1.5 years...so, it's not REALLY too late. But, getting that 10 grand back would be rough.
 
#2 ·
I'm an engineer in the semiconductor business. You are right that technicians don't get respect, even though often the technician in our business is extremely valuable. They do get paid fairly well if getting overtime, guys can make 6 figures when they're busy, but if on salary, not so much ($50-60k).

My suggestion to you would be to aim in the long run to start your own business. Lots of BMW techs work at a dealership til they're experienced enough to start their own shop. When you run your own shop, you'll call the shots.

So make your career choices with that goal in mind, and it'll make the lower pay and mundane work more meaningful.

Finally, I think you'll find disillusionment in the work place is the norm, not the exception.
 
#3 ·
And you're right, many of our technicians don't know how to do low level troubleshooting, especially the ones coming from an Air Force background. I get the impression in the Air Force, if the aircraft is down, the techs just yank components out and replace them, they never troubleshoot the components.
 
#4 ·
Ideally, I'd want to make enough money to buy a house and build a garage with a rack next to it and have a big enough customer base to do my own work.

Another thing is...I only want to work 8 hours a day...maybe 9 if I have something to finish.
A lot of techs here stay 12+ hours a day. I don't want to live like that. I feel like I won't succeed because of that.


But, yeah. I feel like the good techs aren't paid well enough. Anyone can hook up a computer to something and figure out what's wrong (kind of), but what about when something doesn't go according to plan?