BMW Forum - BimmerFest BMW Forums banner

Curt hitch or Invisihitch?? for my 2014 X3 M sport

3.8K views 12 replies 6 participants last post by  wingless  
#1 ·
Hey y'all,

Has anyone ever installed a Curt hitch on their X3 WITH a wiring harness to tow a trailer? I'll be towing two motorcycles to the race track a couple times a year.

I like the ease of the Invisihitch, and I've seen great reviews here about it, so I know that's an option but I'm looking to save some $$ if possible and I really don't mind the look of a receiver behind my X3 so also looking at the Curt. However I haven't been able to find any explanations on the net of the wiring install on a Curt and etrailer.com doesn't list any wiring setups available for the 2014 X3. :dunno:

If this has been answered anywhere on the forum, I wasn't able to find it. Any and all help would be greatly appreciated!

cheers
 
#2 ·
I'm 100% positive that Etrailer has a wiring harness for our cars. Here's their install video:

https://www.etrailer.com/tv-install-trailer-wiring-2013-bmw-x3-119190kit.aspx

It's not a really clean install with the wiring adapter under the car, as they just run it from the trunk and let it hang out of the car, but if you're just doing this a couple of times a year, I think that's a fine option to save $, or I guess there must be a way to route it under the car, just more work...

Not sure if A) it's possible to buy the Invisihitch wiring harness if you've not bought a hitch from them. B) They indicated in a post they feel their harness controller has some more safety features built into it and can't mess up the car's electricals compared to the plain Curt one, which just uses a fuse or something. I can't seem to find that post though for the life of me...

Hopefully they can address the above two points in this thread.

Some other posts related to this topic:

http://www.bimmerfest.com/forums/showthread.php?t=831322
.
 
#3 ·
Lotus99,

Thanks a lot for the response. I did some more research on the etrailer one you linked me to and though it was listed for a 2013 not the 2014, I called etrailer customer service and they got in touch with the wiring harness manufacturer who said that the one shown in the video works up to the 2015 model X3.
 
#4 ·
Good to know. Would have been odd for the 2014 and 2013 not to be the same, but even for an LCI X3, I wouldn't have imagined anything had changed, though updated taillights for example, might have had an impact.
 
#6 ·
Lotus99 touched on this, but Invisihitch generally differentiates itself from less expensive hitches in 3 ways:

1. The aesthetic advantage of not seeing a hitch on your vehicle during the 99% of time that you are not using it. (This does not appear to be a concern to you, so perhaps no advantage in this case).

2. Our wiring harnesses, which were designed in cooperation with BMW. Other than the BMW dealer hitch, our X3 hitch is the only hitch that can be ordered with the North American OEM harnesss. The OEM harness integrates with the X3's other intelligent systems. Specifically, it deactivates the rear park sensors when a trailer is plugged in, it monitors for trailer bulb outages, and it activates Trailer Stability Control which intercedes with braking to stop repetitive trailer sway or "trailer snaking".

We also offer a less expensive X3 passive harness that simply activates the trailer bulbs appropriately. The primary advantage of this harness over aftermarket alternatives is the fact that the harness and its controller were designed with and submitted to BMW for their testing and approval before being released for use on the X3.

We do not sell any of our wiring harness independently. They are only available with our hitches. Other hitch companies are welcome to invest their own resources in working directly with BMW should they choose to do so. I hope you understand.

3. Our hitch completely preserves the rear crumple zones of the X3, which is important in a rear-end collision. As an OE hitch supplier to BMW (which we are in other regions of the world), we had to pass stringent testing on this issue. Just by looking at some of the aftermarket hitches, I can tell that they do not preserve the rear crumple zones. To do so, the full length of the hitch beam must remain in the exact plane of the bumper and at the exact height of the bumper. The hitch must also attach to the chassis only where the bumper attaches, so that crash forces are transferred by the hitch beam into the chassis crumple zones the way the designers of the vehicle intended.

If aesthetics are not a concern, then your trade-offs of features-versus-price are in the wiring and in crumple-zone preservation. Each person's situation and their level of concern for those two issues may be unique. I know that there are alternatives, and I realize that Invisihitch is a premium solution, but I believe that is a pretty fair analysis of the differences.

Daryl
daryl@invisihitch.com

 
#7 ·
Thanks Daryl for chiming in. Could you please expand a bit on the difference between your harness and the others on the market? I was positive I had read a sentence or two from you somewhere indicating why yours had more safety features built into it, vs. what a Curt one for example has, and the impact of the lack thereof (potential scenario of what could happen with a Curt, which wouldn't with yours).

I thought you had posted something similar to that, but can't find it...
 
#8 ·
Thanks Daryl for chiming in. Could you please expand a bit on the difference between your harness and the others on the market? I was positive I had read a sentence or two from you somewhere indicating why yours had more safety features built into it, vs. what a Curt one for example has, and the impact of the lack thereof (potential scenario of what could happen with a Curt, which wouldn't with yours).

I thought you had posted something similar to that, but can't find it...
Lotus99, you are basically asking me to make a very "salesy" post -- even more so than I have been occasionally accused of making! Well, ok, if you insist... ;)

Our less-expensive wiring option, the "Passive Harness" is sometimes compared to aftermarket tow harnesses because -- unlike our Active OEM Harness -- it does not plug into the communications bus of the vehicle nor does it integrate directly with BMW's onboard monitoring systems. Instead, it simply listens on the vehicle's taillights and, in turn, generates its own signals to the trailer bulbs. Aftermarket harnesses generally take that same approach.

However, the controller on our Passive Harness is a BMW-specific controller. It was developed with BMW, tested and certified by BMW, and this harness/controller combination is offered by BMW as a wiring option in some price-sensitive regions of the world.

Other distinguishing features of our Passive Harness are:

• Support for surge brakes. I know of no aftermarket X3 harness that provides the reverse-signal output, which is necessary to lock out trailer surge brakes when backing up.

• Support for up to 20 trailer running lights. Many aftermarket harnesses support only one lamp per side for the trailer taillights (running lights), but modern trailers often have multiple running lights. In a current-overload situation, either the aftermarket-harness controller will shut itself down or a fuse will be blown (and re-blown as soon as you replace it).

• Support for +12v (30amp) at the trailer plug. If you have a camper or RV with internal power outlets, or if you ever want to add a wireless brake controller, or if you want to charge your trailer battery in transit, you will need the harness to output a 12v power signal.

• Intelligent bulb substitution. Our controller constantly monitors trailer bulbs in realtime, and it automatically takes safety actions to mitigate the effects of bulb outages. As an example, in the event that the trailer's left-side taillight burns out, our controller will immediately detect the fault and begin sending a 50%-intensity signal to the left-side brake light, causing it to glow dimly like a taillight. Whenever the brakes are applied, the signal will be increased to 100% intensity.

• Anti-feedback assurance. This is a direct consequence of working with BMW on the development and testing of the controller. There are multiple built-in safeguards to ensure that no current can ever be fed back to the vehicle's wiring and its electronics, regardless of the condition of the trailer wiring and regardless of possible power-outages or power surges to the controller. All aftermarket harnesses that I know of simply fuse their connection to the battery as their only protection of the vehicle.

We are aware that most customers purchase our hitch for its aesthetic advantages. That is how most people make their buying decision, and we market our hitch accordingly. However, far more of our engineering resources go into preserving the vehicle's crumple zones and protecting the vehicle's expensive wiring/electronics than hiding the hitch. These features may not have the same marketing pizazz as making the hitch invisible, but they are a huge part of who we are as a hitch company. So thank you for asking.

Daryl
daryl@invisihitch.com

 
#10 ·
Our passive harness will have the exact same connections at the hitch as the oem active harness, provided that you order it with a 7-way round trailer receptacle. (The oem active harness comes ONLY in a 7-way round trailer receptacle). We can also supply the passive harness with a 5-way flat trailer connector, in which case you sacrifice having the +12v signal. Or we can supply the passive harness with a 4-way flat connector, in which case you also sacrifice the surge-brake lockout signal. In all cases, you get anti-feedback assurance, intelligent bulb substitution, and support for up to 20 running lights on the trailer.

As of the date of this posting, there is only one plug-and-play tow harness available for the X3 -- the oem active harness. All other X3 tow harnesses tap the taillight wires, including our passive harness

Daryl
daryl@invisihitch.com